A bigger commercial solar system will generate more electricity. But it will not necessarily produce the biggest saving.
In this anonymised Solar Power Purchase Agreement reviewed by ELS, three Solar PV systems were modelled for the same UK business.
The 652.5kWp option produced the highest modelled first-year saving at £34,178, even though a larger 877.5kWp system generated considerably more electricity.
Why?
Because a good Solar PPA is not simply about fitting as many panels as possible.
It is about matching generation, onsite electricity demand, self-consumption and the funding structure to what the business is trying to achieve.
What was the commercial solar project?
The project involved a UK temperature-controlled logistics operation using approximately 1.33 million kWh of electricity each year.
The business wanted to explore commercial Solar PV without making a large upfront capital investment.
A PPA-funded solution was therefore modelled using the site’s electricity consumption data.
Rather than proposing one system, three different sizes were compared.
That allowed the business to see how increasing the size of the solar installation affected:
- electricity generation
- onsite consumption
- electricity exported
- PPA pricing
- first-year savings
- long-term savings
How did the three Solar PPA options compare?
Here is the key comparison.
| Option 1 | Option 2 | Option 3 | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Solar PV system | 427.5kWp | 652.5kWp | 877.5kWp |
| Solar generation | 398,409 kWh | 587,315 kWh | 771,823 kWh |
| Self-consumption | 90% | 75% | 63% |
| Site electricity supplied by solar | 27% | 33% | 37% |
| Proposed PPA rate | 10.9p/kWh | 11.9p/kWh | 12.95p/kWh |
| Customer capital investment | £0 | £0 | £0 |
| Modelled first-year saving | £31,342 | £34,178 | £32,828 |
| Modelled 25-year cumulative saving | £1.466m | £1.662m | £1.680m |
That comparison tells a much more useful story than system size alone.
The 877.5kWp option generated around 184,500 kWh more electricity than the 652.5kWp option.
Yet the 652.5kWp system produced the higher modelled first-year saving.
At the same time, the largest option produced the highest modelled cumulative saving over 25 years.
So which system was best?
It depends on what the business wants to optimise.
Why did the 652.5kWp option produce the highest first-year saving?
The 652.5kWp option struck a stronger balance between additional solar generation and the amount of that electricity the business could use onsite.
Its modelled self-consumption was 75%.
By comparison:
- the 427.5kWp system achieved 90% self-consumption
- the 877.5kWp system fell to 63%
The smaller system used a higher proportion of everything it generated, but produced less electricity overall.
The largest system produced much more electricity, but a greater proportion had to be exported.
The middle option sat between the two.
That is why commercial Solar PV system sizing cannot be reduced to:
“How many panels can we fit?”
A better question is:
“How much solar electricity can this business use productively?”
Does that mean the 652.5kWp system was the best option?
Not automatically.
This is an important distinction.
The 652.5kWp system produced the highest modelled first-year saving.
But the 877.5kWp system produced the highest modelled 25-year cumulative saving, at approximately £1.68 million compared with £1.66 million for the middle option.
The larger system also increased the proportion of the site’s electricity demand met by solar from 33% to 37%.
That means the correct choice depends partly on the business’s priorities.
A company focused heavily on current-year economics may look at the project differently from one expecting electricity demand to increase substantially over the next decade.
There is rarely one useful number that answers the whole question.
Why does self-consumption matter in a Solar PPA?
Self-consumption is the proportion of the solar electricity generated that the business actually uses onsite.
For example, a 75% self-consumption rate means the site is expected to use around three quarters of the electricity produced by the Solar PV system.
The remainder is exported.
For an onsite commercial PPA, that matters because electricity used by the business is directly replacing electricity it would otherwise need to source elsewhere.
But maximising self-consumption alone is not the goal either.
Option 1 achieved the highest self-consumption at 90%, yet produced the lowest first-year saving of the three models.
So there are two extremes to avoid:
Install too little: very high self-consumption, but potentially leave useful savings on the table.
Install too much: generate significantly more electricity, but export a growing proportion of it.
Good modelling looks for the balance that fits the business.
Why did future electricity demand affect the recommendation?
Because the right system size today may not be the right system size for the next 25 years.
The proposal specifically considered potential increases in future electricity demand.
That could come from things such as:
- additional production
- electric vehicle charging
- electrification of heating
- new machinery
- longer operating hours
- site expansion
If demand is expected to stay relatively static, a smaller system with higher self-consumption may make more sense.
If demand is expected to increase, a larger system may become more attractive because more of its generation can eventually be consumed onsite.
That is why good Solar PPA modelling should consider where the business is going, not just where its electricity consumption is today.
What did the 652.5kWp Solar PPA look like?
For a business wanting a concrete Solar Power Purchase Agreement example, the middle option looked like this:
| Project measure | Modelled figure |
|---|---|
| Solar PV system | 652.5kWp |
| Number of panels | 1,305 |
| Customer investment | £0 |
| Year-one solar generation | 587,315 kWh |
| Self-consumption | 75% |
| Site electricity demand supplied by solar | 33% |
| Proposed PPA rate | 11.9p/kWh |
| PPA term | 25 years |
| Modelled first-year saving | £34,178 |
| Modelled 25-year cumulative saving | £1,661,796 |
The proposal assumed annual PPA indexation and modelled future electricity pricing as part of the cash-flow analysis.
Those assumptions matter.
A Solar PPA should therefore be assessed as a complete commercial model, not simply on its starting PPA price per kWh.
Why wasn’t battery storage added?
Battery storage was considered, but was not commercially attractive for this project under the PPA structure at that time.
That decision is useful.
A battery could allow more solar electricity to be stored and consumed later, increasing self-consumption.
But if the additional funding cost outweighs that extra value, the economics can become worse rather than better.
So adding more technology is not automatically an improvement.
The proposal instead left battery storage open for future reassessment if technology costs reduced or the site’s demand profile changed. We explore the numbers behind that decision in our guide to commercial battery storage in the UK.
What does this Solar PPA example tell other businesses?
There are four useful lessons.
Bigger is not automatically better
The largest system generated the most electricity, but the middle option produced the highest first-year saving.
Smaller is not automatically better either
The smallest system achieved 90% self-consumption, but delivered the lowest first-year saving.
Future demand can change the answer
If electricity use is likely to increase, today’s apparently oversized system may become tomorrow’s better-fit system.
The right answer comes from modelling the business, not the roof
Roof space tells you what you can install.
Electricity data and commercial modelling help determine what you should install.
That is the distinction that matters.
Could a Solar PPA work for your business?
This project was modelled around one business’s energy profile, roof space and future plans.
Your numbers will be different.
A commercial Solar PPA can potentially fund a new Solar PV system without requiring a large upfront capital investment, but the system needs to be sized around the commercial reality of the site.
ELS can look at your electricity consumption, proposed system, expected generation and future energy plans to explore what the numbers could look like.
If you are considering commercial Solar PV and want to understand which PPA structure makes commercial sense, let’s look at the numbers.
This article is based on an anonymised commercial Solar PPA proposal reviewed by ELS. All savings and generation figures are modelled rather than guaranteed. Projects remain subject to technical assessment, structural suitability, grid connection requirements, final commercial terms and actual energy performance.

